Plum Tickled Farm Stand

We're Just Plum Tickled You're Here!

A family run farm stand featuring homegrown veggies, fresh baked goods, seasoning blends, and more!

Explore
Limited-time ordering

Upcoming Dates & Drops

Reserve from the next pickup windows, special menus, and limited releases.

Orders open27 items

Second November Drop

Wed, Nov 25 · 7:00 AM - 4:00 PM · Professional Arts Building

⏰ Orders close in:3d 3h 3m
Photo of Blueberry Sourdough Bagel

Blueberry Sourdough Bagel

$3.50 - $18.00

Brown Sugar Cinnamon Sourdough Loaf

Brown Sugar Cinnamon Sourdough Loaf

$12.00

Photo of Orange Cranberry White Chocolate Chip Cookie

Orange Cranberry White Chocolate Chip Cookie

$5.00 - $45.00

Photo of Brown Butter Rice Cereal Treats

Brown Butter Rice Cereal Treats

$4.00

Subscriber Access

Get first access to drops, pre-orders, and announcements

Enter your email to unlock the full experience with Plum Tickled Farm Stand — track orders, get notifications, and more.

Benefits:

  • Track orders
  • Live chat with Plum Tickled Farm Stand
  • Customize notifications
  • Benefit from loyalty rewards

We'll send a quick verification code

Get emails without creating an account

By submitting my phone number, I agree to receive recurring automated marketing text messages and shop alerts from Plum Tickled Farm Stand powered by Cottage CMS. Consent is not required to purchase. Message and data rates may apply. Message frequency varies. Reply HELP for help. Reply STOP to stop event texts. View our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Why Choose Us

Quality, trust, and community at the heart of everything

🌱

Locally Grown Produce

Sourced from our own gardens, straight to the stand

👨‍🍳

Small Batch

Handcrafted in small batches with all the love, and none of that extra stuff

📍

Community Focused

Proudly serving our community what we are proud to serve our family

💜

Family Run

Family run small business dedicated to providing service so good, you'll think you're part of the family!

Customer Reviews

What customers are saying

Real notes from recent orders.

5.09 reviews

Perfect cookies.

These cookies were so good, my guests couldn't stop raving about them. The toffee chocolate chip was so rich and I loved the dash of salt on top to help cut the richness, and that was the best dang snicker doodle I've ever had. These were soft in the middle, but a little firm on the outsides and loaded with flavor. I ordered a lot for a baby shower and my guests ate them ALL!

OrderedPhoto of Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Toffee CookiesChocolate Chip Toffee Cookies - DozenPumpkin Spice Snickerdoodles - Dozen
RM

Rui M.

Verified purchase

Apple Cider Scones

The apple scones were so delicious. They had just the right amount of sugar paired perfectly with the warm, yummy fall spices.

OrderedApple Cider Scones - 4 Pack
SS

Sheila S.

Verified purchase

Best Lottle Farm Stand in Indiana

Such treats should be delicious and cutely packaged....and they are! Such a nice surprise for yourself or someone else. The cookies are perfectly soft and full of flavor. They will keep you coming back for more. Don't pass by without ordering from the helpful staff. The best your gonna find, made with country goodness and a bit of love.

CC

Chuck C.

Verified purchase

Dangerously good

I tried the bagels, chocolate chip cookies AND the cinnamon roll, and every single thing was AMAZING. Honestly, some of the best I’ve ever had— The bagels were absolutely delicious(and I am a New Yorker I know my bagels ), the chocolate chip cookies were dangerously good, and that cinnamon roll… WOW. 🤤 Soft, fresh, perfectly sweet, and basically impossible to share. 😂 You can tell how much love and care goes into everything they make. If you haven’t tried them yet, DO IT! Your taste buds will thank you… your diet may not. 😂❤️ Seriously, such an awesome small business and I can’t recommend them enough! 🥯🍪❤️

C

Carrie

Our Story

What started as a passion for baking and tending to gardens to feed our family, has now blossomed into sharing those passions with our community for all to enjoy.

Read Our Full Story